4. How Are Charter Schools Funded?
Top Takeaways
- The charter-district funding gap widened in FY2024. In 2023-24 (i.e., FY2024), charter schools received about 80 cents for every dollar received by district schools, a shortfall of $4,291 per student, compared with gaps of roughly $3,000 to $4,000 per student from FY2020 to FY2023. Part of the increase is due to the inclusion of New York, which met our data coverage requirements for the first time this year; excluding New York, the FY2024 gap is $3,279.
- Charter schools rely more on state revenues and less on local revenues than district schools. In FY2024, 55% of charter revenue came from state sources, compared with 45% for districts. This reliance leaves charters more vulnerable when state budgets tighten.
- The gap between charter and district school revenue varies significantly by state. In FY2024, charters received less funding than districts in 26 of 31 states with available data, with gaps exceeding $6,000 per pupil in New York, Connecticut, West Virginia, and Maine.
- Funding inequities persist in major cities. In 2019-20, across 18 charter-rich cities such as New York City, Los Angeles, and Houston, charters received $7,147 less per pupil than district schools.
How Do Public Charter Schools Receive Funding?
On average, public charter schools receive fewer dollars per pupil than district schools. Charter school local education agencies (LEAs) and charter-only districts typically operate with less revenue, receiving about 80 cents for every dollar received by district schools in FY2024. This translates to an average shortfall of $4,291 per student (Table 4.1). Although year-to-year figures fluctuate, charter schools received less per pupil than district schools in every year examined.
Public schools have three primary sources of funding: federal, state, and local revenues. The mix of these sources differs for charter and district schools. District schools tend to rely more heavily on local revenues, especially property taxes, while charter schools receive a larger share of their funding from state sources and much less from local revenues. As a result, charter school funding is more directly tied to state policy choices and appropriations, making it especially sensitive to changes in state budgets and legislation.
The National Alliance analyzed data on public school funding from the National Center for Education Statistics School District Finance Survey (F-33) for FY2020 through FY2024. To ensure comparability across years, all dollar amounts were adjusted for inflation using the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation calculator, with September of the initial school year serving as the reference month. For example, the adjustment from FY2023 to FY2024 reflects the Consumer Price Index change between September 2022 and September 2023. See the methodology page for more details.
The national trend shows (Table 4.1):
- The charter-district revenue gap narrowed from $3,942 in FY2021 to $3,043 in FY2023, then widened to $4,291 in FY2024, the largest gap in the five-year period. Excluding New York, which enters the analysis this year, the FY2024 gap is $3,279.
- Federal shares have declined in both sectors since peaking in FY2022 (charters: 15.7% to 12.1%; districts: 13.6% to 10.5%), consistent with pandemic-era relief (Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief and related aid) winding down.
- Charters continued to rely more on state dollars (55%) and less on local dollars (33%) than districts (state 45%, local 44%). The rise in the charter local share from 27% in FY2023 largely reflects New York, where 77% of charter revenue is reported as local.
Table 4.1: Per-Pupil Revenues Trend (PPR) by Sector Over Time
| Fiscal Year | Charter Per-Pupil Revenue | Charter – Federal | Charter – State | Charter – Local | District Per-Pupil Revenue | District – Federal | District – State | District – Local | Charter – District PPR Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 15,090.13 | 7.80% | 61.38% | 30.83% | 18,054.40 | 7.07% | 47.66% | 45.27% | -2,964.27 |
| 2021 | 15,510.02 | 11.50% | 59.56% | 28.94% | 19,451.67 | 10.36% | 45.94% | 43.70% | -3,941.65 |
| 2022 | 16,685.40 | 15.70% | 57.10% | 27.19% | 19,946.64 | 13.59% | 44.14% | 42.27% | -3,261.24 |
| 2023 | 16,801.47 | 14.78% | 58.26% | 26.96% | 19,844.54 | 12.07% | 45.04% | 42.89% | -3,043.07 |
| 2024 | 17,282.55 | 12.06% | 55.10% | 32.84% | 21,573.87 | 10.46% | 45.44% | 44.09% | -4,291.32 |
Data Notes: Funding differences should be interpreted with caution, as the set of LEAs and states included in the cleaned dataset varies by year. FY2024 is the first year in which New York meets the state coverage threshold, because finance data for its charter schools are now reported in the F-33; excluding New York, FY2024 per-pupil revenue is $16,772.23 for charters and $20,050.96 for districts (difference: -$3,278.73). FY2020–FY2023 figures are calculated from NCES’s final F-33 files (2a) and may differ slightly from earlier versions of this page, which used provisional files (1a). Additional information about the National Alliance’s cleaning process and analytical approach can be found on the methodology page. All figures have been adjusted for inflation and are reported in September 2023 dollars.
At the state level (Table 4.2):
- In the most recent year of available data (FY2024, or the 2023-24 school year), per-pupil revenue in charter school LEAs was less than per-pupil revenue in district schools in 26 of the 31 states for which we have data.
- The average national gap is about $4,291 per pupil, but the disparity is far more severe in some states. For example, New York (-$14,874), Connecticut (-$11,661), and West Virginia (-$11,121) show large deficits for charter schools. In contrast, charters received more per pupil than districts in Missouri (+$4,565), Massachusetts (+$3,802), and Alabama (+$3,365), and were near parity in Mississippi (+$655) and Washington (+$574).
- Nationally, 55% of charter revenues come from state sources, compared to 45% for districts. In states like West Virginia (89%), Utah (88%), and Minnesota (86%), charters are overwhelmingly reliant on state appropriations, making them especially vulnerable to state-level policy shifts.
Table 4.2: Per-Pupil Revenues (PPR) by State by Sector, FY2024
| State | Charter Per-Pupil Revenue | Charter – Federal | Charter – State | Charter – Local | District Per-Pupil Revenue | District – Federal | District – State | District – Local | Charter – District PPR Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | 20,769.51* | 13.98% | 72.84% | 13.18% | 17,404.48 | 15.70% | 52.63% | 31.67% | 3,365.02 |
| Arizona | 12,513.48 | 11.96% | 80.61% | 7.43% | 15,823.31 | 18.24% | 46.55% | 35.21% | -3,309.82 |
| Arkansas | 11,829.42* | 16.92% | 78.27% | 4.80% | 15,582.54* | 14.31% | 46.08% | 39.61% | -3,753.12 |
| California | 18,560.76* | 6.65% | 69.25% | 24.10% | 24,254.04* | 9.39% | 51.28% | 39.33% | -5,693.28 |
| Connecticut | 17,376.54 | 18.53% | 70.81% | 10.66% | 29,037.70 | 7.60% | 36.20% | 56.20% | -11,661.16 |
| Delaware | 17,650.50 | 10.71% | 58.99% | 30.30% | 23,517.30 | 10.83% | 57.27% | 31.90% | -5,866.80 |
| District of Columbia | 35,469.69 | 9.98% | 0.00% | 90.02% | 37,886.33 | 13.87% | 0.00% | 86.13% | -2,416.64 |
| Georgia | 14,195.04* | 12.80% | 82.22% | 4.98% | 17,583.76* | 12.73% | 44.07% | 43.20% | -3,388.72 |
| Idaho | 11,853.36 | 9.02% | 84.19% | 6.79% | 13,506.82 | 12.24% | 66.51% | 21.25% | -1,653.45 |
| Indiana | 15,873.80 | 22.99% | 65.61% | 11.40% | 17,400.63 | 11.11% | 55.51% | 33.38% | -1,526.84 |
| Iowa | 17,317.07* | 28.92% | 48.29% | 22.79% | 17,867.02 | 7.56% | 49.15% | 43.29% | -549.95 |
| Louisiana | 16,725.47* | 18.67% | 34.89% | 46.44% | 18,332.56* | 17.87% | 35.90% | 46.23% | -1,607.08 |
| Maine | 14,217.71 | 9.79% | 84.97% | 5.24% | 22,142.60 | 7.90% | 39.62% | 52.47% | -7,924.89 |
| Massachusetts | 30,629.67 | 10.54% | 15.22% | 74.24% | 26,827.32 | 8.30% | 42.87% | 48.84% | 3,802.35 |
| Michigan | 14,745.87 | 17.74% | 75.64% | 6.62% | 20,556.44 | 9.44% | 56.84% | 33.72% | -5,810.57 |
| Minnesota | 18,431.87 | 9.47% | 86.10% | 4.43% | 20,732.44 | 7.76% | 62.13% | 30.10% | -2,300.57 |
| Mississippi | 15,971.55 | 30.69% | 39.48% | 29.83% | 15,316.76 | 22.62% | 44.85% | 32.53% | 654.79 |
| Missouri | 21,740.78 | 19.88% | 65.02% | 15.10% | 17,176.11 | 11.25% | 26.88% | 61.87% | 4,564.67 |
| New Jersey | 26,867.02 | 13.37% | 11.16% | 75.47% | 31,374.91 | 6.21% | 45.95% | 47.84% | -4,507.89 |
| New Mexico | 18,685.32* | 13.88% | 78.61% | 7.51% | 23,162.54* | 20.05% | 65.21% | 14.73% | -4,477.22 |
| New York | 24,461.20 | 8.52% | 14.81% | 76.67% | 39,335.53 | 8.31% | 40.66% | 51.03% | -14,874.33 |
| North Carolina | 11,917.53 | 8.56% | 62.56% | 28.88% | 14,254.65 | 17.38% | 57.08% | 25.54% | -2,337.12 |
| Ohio | 14,870.63 | 23.23% | 72.07% | 4.70% | 19,398.86 | 11.85% | 34.65% | 53.49% | -4,528.22 |
| Oklahoma | 10,948.73 | 17.27% | 76.84% | 5.89% | 14,431.61 | 13.84% | 44.63% | 41.52% | -3,482.88 |
| Pennsylvania | 23,132.36 | 14.79% | 0.94% | 84.27% | 26,442.25 | 8.34% | 36.89% | 54.78% | -3,309.89 |
| Rhode Island | 22,232.34 | 14.75% | 58.82% | 26.44% | 24,710.17* | 9.45% | 36.64% | 53.91% | -2,477.84 |
| South Carolina | 13,537.10 | 7.69% | 82.47% | 9.84% | 18,501.17* | 13.52% | 47.07% | 39.41% | -4,964.07 |
| Texas | 14,167.42 | 15.50% | 78.60% | 5.89% | 15,986.72 | 12.04% | 37.69% | 50.27% | -1,819.30 |
| Utah | 12,551.10 | 6.48% | 87.75% | 5.77% | 14,196.45 | 7.91% | 50.52% | 41.57% | -1,645.34 |
| Washington | 22,193.81 | 13.54% | 73.71% | 12.75% | 21,620.01 | 7.90% | 65.63% | 26.47% | 573.80 |
| West Virginia | 8,251.21 | 6.80% | 89.12% | 4.08% | 19,372.37 | 18.02% | 46.30% | 35.68% | -11,121.17 |
| National | 17,282.55 | 12.06% | 55.10% | 32.84% | 21,573.87 | 10.46% | 45.44% | 44.09% | -4,291.32 |
Data Notes: States are included only when both charter and traditional public school (TPS, or district schools) enrollment in the cleaned F-33 data represent at least 50% of each sector’s statewide enrollment. States with less than 50% coverage are excluded, and those with 50-79% coverage are marked with an asterisk*. Data Notes: States are included only when both charter and traditional public school (TPS, or district schools) enrollment in the cleaned F-33 data represent at least 50% of each sector’s statewide enrollment. States with less than 50% coverage are excluded, and those with 50-79% coverage are marked with an asterisk*. Iowa, New York, and West Virginia appear in this table for the first time; Iowa and West Virginia have very small charter sectors (2 and 5 charter LEAs, respectively), so their figures should be interpreted with caution.
School Spending Overview
As shown in Table 4.3, charter schools have consistently spent less per pupil than district schools over the five-year period from FY2020 to FY2024. The gap has averaged more than $4,400 per student annually, narrowing from $5,092 in FY2021 to $3,682 in FY2023 before widening to $5,508 in FY2024. As with revenues, New York’s inclusion contributes to the FY2024 increase; excluding New York, the FY2024 gap is $4,331.
Table 4.3: Per-Pupil Expenditure (PPE) Trend by Sector Over Time (Inflation-Adjusted, Sept 2023 Dollars)
| Fiscal Year | Charter Per-Pupil Expenditure | District Per-Pupil Expenditure | Charter – District PPE Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 14,236.05 | 18,418.59 | -4,182.54 |
| 2021 | 14,190.13 | 19,282.41 | -5,092.28 |
| 2022 | 15,839.62 | 19,705.60 | -3,865.98 |
| 2023 | 15,899.87 | 19,581.66 | -3,681.79 |
| 2024 | 16,144.69 | 21,652.53 | -5,507.84 |
Data Notes: Sector-level funding differences should be interpreted with caution, as the set of LEAs and states included in the cleaned dataset varies by year. Excluding New York, FY2024 per-pupil expenditure is $15,824.94 for charters and $20,155.45 for districts (difference: -$4,330.51). FY2020–FY2023 figures are calculated from NCES’s final F-33 files (2a) and may differ slightly from earlier versions of this page, which used provisional files (1a). Additional information about the National Alliance’s cleaning process and analytical approach can be found on the methodology page. All figures have been adjusted for inflation and are reported in September 2023 dollars.
At the state level (Table 4.4), charter-district spending gaps are wide and persistent. In FY2024, charter schools spent less per pupil than district schools in 28 of 31 states. In 11 states, including New York, Connecticut, and New Jersey, the charter–district expenditure gap exceeded $5,000 per student.
These disparities stem largely from differences in access to funding streams. District schools benefit from local property tax revenues, which charters in most states cannot access directly. This allows districts to spend more on categories such as facilities, staffing, and student services. By contrast, charters rely more heavily on state appropriations, and their tighter budgets often translate into leaner expenditures across multiple areas.
Table 4.4: Per-Pupil Expenditures (PPE) by State by Sector, FY2024
| State | Charter Per-Pupil Expenditure | District Per-Pupil Expenditure | Charter – District PPE Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | 19,058.29* | 16,195.30 | 2,862.99 |
| Arizona | 12,626.11 | 14,938.55 | -2,312.44 |
| Arkansas | 11,745.78* | 16,062.18* | -4,316.40 |
| California | 17,758.48* | 23,553.65* | -5,795.17 |
| Connecticut | 17,368.07 | 29,070.44 | -11,702.37 |
| Delaware | 18,042.28 | 24,972.89 | -6,930.62 |
| District of Columbia | 33,873.60 | 39,193.57 | -5,319.97 |
| Georgia | 13,312.48* | 17,510.10* | -4,197.62 |
| Idaho | 11,082.54 | 12,345.31 | -1,262.77 |
| Indiana | 14,688.83 | 17,265.62 | -2,576.79 |
| Iowa | 23,605.69* | 17,844.67 | 5,761.02 |
| Louisiana | 16,266.00* | 17,938.84* | -1,672.84 |
| Maine | 14,034.98 | 22,071.29 | -8,036.31 |
| Massachusetts | 26,837.61 | 28,879.49 | -2,041.88 |
| Michigan | 14,287.02 | 20,509.58 | -6,222.56 |
| Minnesota | 18,760.03 | 20,890.71 | -2,130.68 |
| Mississippi | 14,580.60 | 14,784.43 | -203.83 |
| Missouri | 20,534.99 | 16,848.20 | 3,686.80 |
| New Jersey | 24,702.67 | 31,305.47 | -6,602.81 |
| New Mexico | 17,259.14* | 20,926.89* | -3,667.75 |
| New York | 20,642.58 | 39,112.92 | -18,470.34 |
| North Carolina | 12,188.75 | 15,087.59 | -2,898.85 |
| Ohio | 14,031.94 | 19,042.60 | -5,010.66 |
| Oklahoma | 11,359.40 | 14,156.63 | -2,797.23 |
| Pennsylvania | 21,333.63 | 25,986.66 | -4,653.03 |
| Rhode Island | 21,578.89 | 24,775.59* | -3,196.70 |
| South Carolina | 15,060.30 | 17,867.20* | -2,806.91 |
| Texas | 11,804.54 | 17,693.85 | -5,889.32 |
| Utah | 12,236.60 | 14,109.64 | -1,873.04 |
| Washington | 20,876.43 | 21,441.33 | -564.91 |
| West Virginia | 8,838.82 | 18,059.55 | -9,220.73 |
| National | 16,144.69 | 21,652.53 | -5,507.84 |
Data Notes: States are included only when both charter and traditional public school (TPS, or district schools) enrollment in the cleaned F-33 data represent at least 50% of each sector’s statewide enrollment. States with less than 50% coverage are excluded, and those with 50-79% coverage are marked with an asterisk*. Iowa and West Virginia have very small charter sectors (2 and 5 charter LEAs, respectively), so their figures should be interpreted with caution.
Charter School Funding in Cities
In addition to our state and national level analysis, research from the University of Arkansas provides further evidence on charter school funding inequities at the city level. In August 2023, Patrick Wolf, Ph.D. and team at the University of Arkansas released a study examining charter school funding across 18 cities: Atlanta, Boston, Camden, Chicago, Denver, Detroit, Indianapolis, Houston, Little Rock, Los Angeles, Memphis, New Orleans, New York City, Oakland, Phoenix, San Antonio, Tulsa, and Washington, D.C.
The study found that in 2019-20, charter schools across 18 cities in 16 states, on average, received $7,147 less funding per pupil than district schools. This equates to 29.5% less per pupil compared to district schools in these cities. Compared to the previous study that examined the data from the 2017-18 school year, there has been an over 3% decrease in funding disparity between charter schools and district schools. However, the funding gap between the two sectors remains large and has shown little improvement since the early 2000s.
